Diagnosing Corruption-Induced Reliability Failures in Vision-Language Models

arXiv:2511.19032v2 Announce Type: replace Abstract: Visual corruptions can change vision--language model (VLM) behavior in ways that top-1 accuracy does not capture. A model may keep the same answer while losing distributional support, or improve accuracy through unstable wrong-to-correct changes. We introduce Bench-C, a controlled multiple-choice testbed for studying these effects. It selects semantically diverse samples whose predictions respond to corruption, and evaluates them under 19 corruption types and five severity levels. To measure how corruption changes the option distribution, we introduce the Robustness Alignment Score (RAS), which combines confidence-correctness alignment with uncertainty direction. We further separate originally correct samples from originally wrong samples, and track whether changes are temporary or persistent across severity. Experiments across 13 VLMs reveal a counterintuitive pattern: mild corruptions can improve top-1 accuracy while degrading prediction structure. These failures include silent degradation, erroneous overconfidence, and severity-dependent persistence. Bench-C therefore supports robustness evaluation that goes beyond final answers and attributes where reliability changes occur. Code and data are available at https://github.com/xiangjieSui/Bench-C.